Metaphysical painting: de Chirico, Carrà and Morandi — Hroniki
Art movement

Metaphysical painting

1910–1920 · Italy

About the movement

In the autumn of 1910, in Florence, the twenty-two-year-old Giorgio de Chirico, barely recovered from a long illness, was sitting in Piazza Santa Croce. He later described the moment as a revelation: the familiar square suddenly seemed to him as if seen for the first time. Out of that feeling grew The Enigma of an Autumn Afternoon (1910), the first work historians assign to Metaphysical painting. Behind it lay years of study in Munich, the philosophy of Friedrich Nietzsche and the paintings of Arnold Böcklin, from whom de Chirico learned to see an unsettling second layer in the everyday.

Metaphysical painting did not break up form, as the Cubists did, or glorify speed, as the Futurists did. It did the opposite: it stopped time. An empty square with arcades, a shadow falling too long, a train on the horizon, a plaster head beside a rubber glove: everything is painted clearly, almost academically, but the links between things are severed. The unease comes not from distortion but from silence. The perspective in these pictures is deliberately skewed: one building has one vanishing point, the next another, and the eye can find no footing. De Chirico wanted to paint what lies behind the visible, hence the word "metaphysical."

In Paris, where the artist moved in 1911, he caught the eye of Guillaume Apollinaire, who in 1913 was the first to call these pictures metaphysical. From 1914 de Chirico worked with the dealer Paul Guillaume. That same year he painted The Song of Love (1914, Museum of Modern Art, New York), with a plaster head of Apollo and a rubber glove on a wall. Later his pictures were peopled with faceless mannequins, devised together with his brother, the writer and composer Alberto Savinio.

The movement became a school in Ferrara. In 1917 de Chirico and Carlo Carrà, both called up for military service, met in an army hospital and worked side by side for several months. Carrà, until recently a Futurist, exchanged dynamism for stillness and painted The Metaphysical Muse (1917, Pinacoteca di Brera, Milan). The circle was joined by Giorgio Morandi, whose still lifes of 1918–1920 became the most austere version of the style, and Filippo de Pisis, and for a time by Mario Sironi, who later carried metaphysical emptiness into his paintings of urban outskirts. The alliance was short-lived: after Carrà's exhibition in Milan in December 1917, critics began to speak of him as the inventor of the method, which de Chirico took badly. In 1919 Carrà published his book Metaphysical Painting, and that was the end of their relationship.

The group's ideas were promoted by the Roman journal Valori Plastici (1918–1922), but by then both de Chirico and Carrà had turned to Neoclassicism. For de Chirico the turn meant a break with his future admirers: the Surrealists extolled his early work and rejected the later. He returned the hostility, and later painted replicas of his own metaphysical pictures, which still complicates the dating and authentication of his work.

The real life of Metaphysical painting began after it ended. In 1922 the poet Marcel Lecomte showed René Magritte a reproduction of The Song of Love; Magritte recalled that his eyes "saw thought for the first time." André Breton collected early de Chirico, and Max Ernst and Salvador Dalí borrowed his empty spaces and mannequins. In the 1920s the metaphysical silence passed to the Italian Magic Realism of Felice Casorati. Exhibitions in Germany in 1921 and 1924 echoed in the mannequins of George Grosz and Oskar Schlemmer. And Italian architecture of the interwar years, the squares of Brescia and Sabaudia and the EUR district in Rome, at times looks as if it had been built from de Chirico's paintings.

Stories