Minimalism in art: Judd, Flavin, Andre and Stella — Hroniki
Art movement

Minimalism

1960s–1970s · USA

About the movement

In December 1959, visitors to the "Sixteen Americans" exhibition at the Museum of Modern Art in New York saw huge black canvases by the 23-year-old Frank Stella. Stripes the width of a brush, separated by thin lines of bare canvas, depicted nothing and expressed nothing. The Black Paintings (1958–1960) became the starting point for the art that would later be called Minimalism. The word was not coined by the artists themselves: in January 1965 the British philosopher Richard Wollheim published an essay titled "Minimal Art," and he wrote mostly about Duchamp and Ad Reinhardt. The Minimalists disliked the label.

Minimalism set itself against Abstract Expressionism, with its gesture, drama and metaphysics. A work should be exactly what it is. In a 1964 radio conversation with Judd and Flavin, Stella said: "What you see is what you see." In his essay "Specific Objects" (1965), Donald Judd explained why both painting and sculpture felt too confining: better a real object in real space, without illusion and without the kind of composition in which one part balances another. Hence industrial materials, factory fabrication, series and repetition. The way a work was shown mattered too: pieces were set directly on the floor, without a plinth, so that they shared the space with the viewer rather than towering over it. Many works were made in factories from the artist's drawings.

From the mid-1960s Judd made "stacks," identical boxes fixed to the wall one above another. Carl Andre laid out bricks and metal plates on the floor; his Equivalent VIII (1966) consists of 120 firebricks. From 1963 Dan Flavin worked only with fluorescent lights, beginning with the diagonal of May 25, 1963. Robert Morris showed smooth gray polyhedrons, Sol LeWitt open cubic grids. Agnes Martin and Robert Ryman are often counted in this company as painters, although Martin herself felt closer to the Abstract Expressionists.

The exhibition "Primary Structures" at the Jewish Museum in New York (1966, curated by Kynaston McShine) brought the new art into view. The fiercest attack came from the critic Michael Fried. In his essay "Art and Objecthood" (1967) he called Minimalism "literalism" and accused it of theatricality: such an object, Fried argued, waits for the viewer like an actor on a stage. The public's reaction was blunter. The Tate Gallery bought Equivalent VIII in 1972, and when the press learned of the purchase in 1976, the "bricks controversy" broke out. Newspapers asked why taxpayers' money was being spent on bricks, and one visitor poured blue food dye over them.

The Minimalists readily claimed Russian ancestors. From 1964 Dan Flavin returned for decades to his series of light works "monument" for V. Tatlin, and critics traced the movement's lineage to Malevich, Rodchenko and the Constructivists, with their industrial materials and rejection of the "pictorial." The connection was more imagined than direct: many Americans knew the works of the Russian avant-garde only from books such as Camilla Gray's study The Great Experiment: Russian Art 1863–1922 (1962).

Minimalism found its museum not in New York but in the desert. In the 1970s Judd moved to Marfa, Texas, and turned a former army post into a permanent installation; since 1986 it has been run by the Chinati Foundation. Conceptual art, Land art and Post-Minimalism all grew out of Minimalism. And the word itself traveled far beyond the galleries, into architecture, design, fashion and the music of Steve Reich and Philip Glass.