Naturalism in painting: Bastien-Lepage and his circle — Hroniki
Art movement

Naturalism

1870s–1890s · France

About the movement

In the spring of 1878 the Paris Salon showed Haymaking by Jules Bastien-Lepage, a native of the village of Damvillers in the Meuse. The canvas, finished the year before, was praised for its truthfulness, and the 29-year-old pupil of Alexandre Cabanel found himself at the head of a new movement. The word for it was ready and waiting. As early as 1863 the critic Jules-Antoine Castagnary had written of a "naturalist school" for which art was the expression of life in all its forms. Later Émile Zola took up the term and made it the banner of his novels, with their claim to scientific method.

Naturalism grew out of the Realism of Gustave Courbet and Jean-François Millet but lost its political charge. The Naturalists did not denounce; they recorded. They worked outdoors and painted peasants and artisans as they found them, without staging. What set them apart from the Impressionists was their training. The brushwork stayed dense and academically controlled, and the figure was constructed by all the rules of the school. Pascal Dagnan-Bouveret was one of the first to work from photographs, in pursuit of even greater precision.

Bastien-Lepage's major works fit into a few years: Haymaking (1877, Musée d'Orsay), Joan of Arc (1879, Metropolitan Museum of Art), Poor Fauvette (1881, Kelvingrove, Glasgow), Pas Mèche (Nothing Doing) (1882, National Galleries of Scotland) and Village Love (1882). Dagnan-Bouveret, his fellow student in Cabanel's studio and a close friend, painted Wedding at the Photographer's Studio (1879, Musée des Beaux-Arts de Lyon), won a first-class medal at the Salon of 1880 for An Accident, and in 1886 completed The Pardon in Brittany, now in the Metropolitan Museum. Léon Lhermitte made his name with Paying the Harvesters (1882, Musée d'Orsay). His huge Les Halles was shown at the Salon of 1895 and is now in the Petit Palais. Vincent van Gogh admired Lhermitte.

Recognition came quickly, and controversy with it. At the Salon of 1880 critics praised the heroine's face in Joan of Arc, but felt that the saints behind her did not belong in a Naturalist picture. Zola at first supported Bastien-Lepage, then cooled toward him: he saw in his work Impressionism softened and adjusted to popular taste, and took the public's enthusiasm as a bad sign. At the Salon of 1887 The Pardon in Brittany was admired precisely for its photographic accuracy. After Bastien-Lepage's death, Haymaking was bought for the Musée du Luxembourg.

Naturalism has a direct Russian connection. Marie Bashkirtseff (Maria Bashkirtseva), born near Poltava in 1858 and trained at the Académie Julian, was a friend and follower of Bastien-Lepage, though she painted the outskirts of the city rather than the countryside. Her Un meeting (A Meeting) was a success at the Salon of 1884 and is now in the Musée d'Orsay. She died on October 31, 1884, and he on December 10 of the same year. In her diary, published in 1887, she recorded her visits to the dying painter.

In 1885, at the posthumous sale at the Galerie Georges Petit, Sergei Tretyakov bought Village Love, which the Musée du Luxembourg had also had its eye on. Since 1948 the painting has been in the Pushkin State Museum of Fine Arts, which also holds Dagnan-Bouveret's Blessing of the Newlyweds (1880–1881).

The movement had more heirs than such a short life might suggest. The Encyclopaedia Britannica notes that Bastien-Lepage's rural scenes were imitated in France and England. His influence has been seen in George Clausen in England and Tom Roberts in Australia, and the Finnish painter Albert Edelfelt belonged to his circle. Impressionism soon eclipsed Naturalism, and the word came to be used loosely for anything that was neither academic nor modernist. In "An Essay in Aesthetics" (1909), Roger Fry wrote that Bastien-Lepage deftly struck a compromise between truth and familiar convention, and that without such painters the public would never have accepted the truth of Claude Monet.