Neo-primitivism: Larionov, Goncharova and the icon — Hroniki
Russian art movement

Neo-primitivism

c. 1907–1914 · Russia

About the movement

In March 1912, on the eve of the "Donkey's Tail" exhibition in Moscow, the censors removed four canvases from Natalia Goncharova's Evangelists cycle. According to the usual explanation, they decided that sacred images had no place at an exhibition with such a name and such a reputation. It was an almost textbook scandal: young artists were looking to the icon for strength, and the state and the church saw blasphemy. That is how Neo-primitivism, the branch of the Russian avant-garde that sought renewal not in Paris but at home, entered history.

The movement took shape in the late 1900s around Mikhail Larionov and Goncharova. Their sources were the icon, the lubok (the Russian popular print), tavern signboards, painted toys, the ancient stone figures of the steppes and children's drawings. This was not a stylized interest in the past, like that of the World of Art painters, but an attempt to borrow the directness of "low" art: flat color, crude outlines, lettering right on the picture, shifts in scale. Larionov painted Hairdressers (from 1907) and soldiers' lives, as in Resting Soldier (1911, State Tretyakov Gallery); Goncharova painted peasant labor and harvests with a monumental, almost iconlike weight of form.

The movement got its name from Alexander Shevchenko, who in 1913 published the pamphlet Neo-primitivism: Its Theory, Its Potential, Its Achievements. But by then the movement was already well established. In 1910 Larionov helped found the Jack of Diamonds, and in 1912 he left it, accusing his fellow members of dependence on Cézanne and Munich, and organized the "Donkey's Tail." Exhibiting there alongside him and Goncharova were Kazimir Malevich, Marc Chagall, Vladimir Tatlin and Shevchenko. The most provocative works were Larionov's 1912 series of Venuses, Soldier's Venus, Katsap Venus (katsap is a mocking nickname for a Russian) and Jewish Venus, a coarse parody of the classical nude. At the same time came the Seasons cycle, with deliberately ungrammatical inscriptions that look like graffiti on a fence.

Larionov knew how to turn theory into an event. In 1913 he organized an exhibition in Moscow of original icons, lubok prints and signboards, presenting folk art as the equal of modern painting. That spring the "Target" exhibition included works by the self-taught Georgian painter Niko Pirosmani, discovered a year earlier in the taverns of Tiflis (now Tbilisi) by Mikhail Le-Dantiu and the Zdanevich brothers. And in September 1913 a Goncharova retrospective of more than eight hundred works opened at Klavdia Mikhailova's Art Salon. When it traveled to St Petersburg, the censors again removed the religious paintings.

Critics greeted the Neo-primitivists with mockery. The very name "Donkey's Tail," according to the widely accepted version, alluded to a Paris hoax of 1910, when a picture supposedly "painted" with a donkey's tail was shown at the Salon des Indépendants. The newspapers wrote about savages and hooligans. Goncharova replied in a different key in the preface to the catalog of her 1913 exhibition: she announced that she was turning away from the West and would learn from the East and from her own tradition. That stance made Neo-primitivism one of the first movements in Europe to set itself deliberately against the Parisian center.

As an independent movement Neo-primitivism did not last long, roughly until 1914, but it became a launching pad for many. Larionov's Rayonism grew out of it, as did Malevich's early peasant cycles and, through them, the road to Suprematism. Chagall, who had shown at the "Donkey's Tail," carried the same lubok-like tone into his Vitebsk scenes. And the very idea that an icon, a shop sign or a child's drawing could hold its own against museum painting became part of the language of the entire 20th century.