Socialist Realism: the official method of Soviet art — Hroniki
Soviet art movement

Socialist Realism

1932–1980s · USSR

About the movement

Socialist Realism did not grow out of the studios, as Impressionism or Cubism did; it was imposed from above. On April 23, 1932, a resolution of the Communist Party Central Committee, "On the Restructuring of Literary and Artistic Organizations," dissolved all independent groups, from the heirs of the avant-garde to AKhRR, and announced the creation of single creative unions. A month later, on May 23, the term "socialist realism" appeared in print for the first time, in an editorial in Literaturnaya Gazeta. In August 1934, at the First Congress of Soviet Writers, came the formula that would be repeated for half a century: a truthful, historically concrete depiction of reality in its revolutionary development.

The ground had been prepared earlier. From 1922 the Association of Artists of Revolutionary Russia (AKhRR) called for "heroic realism," depicting the life of the Red Army, workers and leaders, and drew on the tradition of the Peredvizhniki, the 19th-century Wanderers. Many of its members later formed the core of official art. Other groups existed alongside it, such as OST, the Circle of Artists and Four Arts, and in the 1920s the argument over what revolutionary art should be was still open. The first major survey of the new era was the exhibition "Artists of the RSFSR over 15 Years," which opened in Leningrad in 1932 and moved to Moscow in 1933. The avant-garde still hung there alongside the realists, but already in separate rooms, as something belonging to the past.

The method demanded accessibility, ideological commitment and narodnost, or closeness to the people. The canonical paintings are Isaak Brodsky's Lenin in Smolny (1930), Boris Ioganson's Interrogation of Communists (1933) and Alexander Gerasimov's Stalin and Voroshilov in the Kremlin (1938), all in the State Tretyakov Gallery. In sculpture the emblem of the style was Vera Mukhina's Worker and Kolkhoz Woman, made for the Soviet pavilion at the 1937 World's Fair in Paris. Alexander Deineka is a more complicated case: his The Defence of Petrograd (1928) was painted before the doctrine existed, in the spirit of OST, and was written into Socialist Realism after the fact.

The limits of the method were set less by theorists than by campaigns. In 1936 the Pravda article "Muddle Instead of Music," an attack on Shostakovich, set off a campaign against formalism that reached the visual arts too. In 1947 the USSR Academy of Arts was founded and became the main body controlling art education and commissions. In 1948 the State Museum of New Western Art, which held the Shchukin and Morozov collections, was closed. After the war a more intimate note entered genre painting, as in Fyodor Reshetnikov's Low Marks Again (1952).

For an artist, Socialist Realism meant above all a system: membership in the Union of Artists, commissions, studios, exhibitions, honorary titles. Those who did not fit in, from Malevich's students to quiet lyrical painters, retreated into book illustration or the theater, or painted "for the drawer." That was the price, and even scholars who see major achievements in Soviet art acknowledge it. At the same time the system offered opportunities unthinkable on a free market: monumental commissions, murals for metro stations, huge thematic exhibitions for which an artist was given years to prepare.

During the Thaw a "Severe Style" emerged within official art: Geli Korzhev, Viktor Popkov, Tahir Salahov and Pavel Nikonov painted builders, geologists and workers without ceremonial optimism, in a restrained, generalized manner. The name was later coined by the critic Alexander Kamensky. In 1962 Nikita Khrushchev's visit to the Manege exhibition marking the 30th anniversary of the Moscow Union of Artists (MOSKh) showed that the limits were as rigid as ever. With the collapse of the USSR the method lost its official status. Today its legacy is studied as a historical phenomenon, and assessments of it, ranging from totalitarian art to the last great academic style, remain a matter of scholarly debate.