Realism in art: Courbet, Millet and modern life — Hroniki
Realism
Art movement

Realism

1840s–1880s · France, Europe and Russia

About the movement

In the summer of 1855, on the Avenue Montaigne in Paris, a stone's throw from the Exposition Universelle, a temporary pavilion went up under a sign that read "Realism." Gustave Courbet had built it at his own expense after the exhibition jury turned down his two largest canvases, A Burial at Ornans and The Painter's Studio. In the catalog of this private show he printed a short text that would soon be called a manifesto. The word itself was already circulating in the arguments over Courbet: the writer Champfleury had championed him, and in 1856–1857 Louis Edmond Duranty published a journal bluntly titled Réalisme.

Courbet put the task simply: "to translate the customs, the ideas and the appearance of my time." Behind the phrase lay an attack on the hierarchy of genres, at whose summit the Academy kept history, mythology and Scripture. The scandal of A Burial at Ornans at the Salon of 1850–1851 lay not in its subject but in its scale: a canvas more than six meters wide, the size of a battle piece, given over to the nameless inhabitants of a provincial town. In an open letter to students in 1861, Courbet declared that painting is "an essentially concrete art." Angels, nymphs and ancient heroes fell outside its limits.

Others worked alongside him. At Barbizon, Jean-François Millet painted peasant labor in The Gleaners (1857) and The Angelus (1857–1859), both now in the Musée d'Orsay. Honoré Daumier spent decades drawing for satirical papers and painted third-class railway carriages and washerwomen. Courbet's The Stone Breakers (1849) was destroyed in Dresden in 1945, but the Burial and the Studio survive in the Orsay. The next generation carried the principle into modern city life: Édouard Manet's Olympia (1863) and Gustave Caillebotte's The Floor Scrapers (1875), rejected by the Salon that same year.

Contemporaries saw Realism less as an aesthetic than as a politics. After the revolution of 1848, pictures of the poor read as a threat: in 1857 the critic Paul de Saint-Victor called The Gleaners "the three Fates of pauperism." At the Salon of 1865 Olympia drew such indignant crowds that guards were posted beside it. Almost twenty years later the same script played out with John Singer Sargent's Madame X (1884): after the scandal the artist repainted the slipped shoulder strap and soon moved to London. Courbet himself was jailed for his part in the Paris Commune of 1871 and the toppling of the Vendôme Column, then left for Switzerland, where he died in 1877.

Beyond France, Realism found masters of its own. In Germany, Adolph Menzel painted The Iron Rolling Mill (1872–1875, Alte Nationalgalerie, Berlin), one of the first large pictures of factory work. The young Max Liebermann made his debut with Women Plucking Geese (1872), and critics, while granting his skill, dubbed him "the painter of ugliness." The Realist line in Europe was carried on by the Belgian Constantin Meunier and the Dutch painters of the Hague School.

In Russia the road to Realism began before Courbet. As early as the 1820s Alexei Venetsianov was painting the peasants of his estate in the Tver province, and in The Major's Marriage Proposal (1848) Pavel Fedotov turned a domestic scene into a comedy of manners. In the second half of the century Realism became the language of Vasily Perov, of Ilya Repin with Barge Haulers on the Volga (1870–1873) and of Vasily Vereshchagin with The Apotheosis of War (1871). This line is traced in detail in our entry on the Peredvizhniki, the society of Russian realists who took their exhibitions on tour across the empire.

As a movement, Realism had left the stage by the 1880s: Manet and his younger friends shifted attention from the subject to light and ways of seeing, while Jules Bastien-Lepage and the Naturalists pushed the method toward near-photographic precision. But the question Courbet had raised (does an ordinary contemporary deserve a large canvas?) never went away. It was asked again by the American Ashcan School, by Germany's New Objectivity and by the Photorealists of the later 20th century.

Artists

Major works

Alexei Bogolyubov, The Mouth of the Neva, 1872The Mouth of the NevaAlexei Bogolyubov · 1872
Vasily Perov, Troika: Apprentices Carrying Water, 1866Troika: Apprentices Carrying WaterVasily Perov · 1866
Isaac Levitan, Golden Autumn, 1895Golden AutumnIsaac Levitan · 1895
Ivan Shishkin, Mast-Tree Grove, 1898Mast-Tree GroveIvan Shishkin · 1898
Vasily Vereshchagin, The Apotheosis of War, 1871The Apotheosis of WarVasily Vereshchagin · 1871
Vasily Perov, Hunters Resting, 1871Hunters RestingVasily Perov · 1871
Nikolai Ge, “What Is Truth?” Christ and Pilate, 1890“What Is Truth?” Christ and PilateNikolai Ge · 1890
Alexei Venetsianov, In the Ploughed Field. Spring, First half of the 1820sIn the Ploughed Field. SpringAlexei Venetsianov · First half of the 1820s
Ivan Kramskoy, An Unknown Woman, 1883An Unknown WomanIvan Kramskoy · 1883
Ivan Shishkin, Morning in a Pine Forest, 1889Morning in a Pine ForestIvan Shishkin · 1889

Stories